There is a season

At the end of last Friday's session with the 3-4 graders we discussed
the seasons. It's natural to think that winter is when we are farther
from the Sun, but is that true?  What evidence can we reason with
here?

Well, for one, we know that when it's winter in the northern
hemisphere, it's summer in the southern hemisphere.  That's a pretty
good clue that the seasons are not caused by the Earth getting closer
to and farther from the Sun.  What else?  One boy, to my amazement,
specifically mentioned that if/when we are closer to the Sun, it
should appear to be bigger, and it doesn't appear to be bigger in
(northern) winter.  I was pretty surprised, but then I recalled that
he had recently seen the movie Agora.  This is a trenchant
observation: the Sun actually looks smallest (as seen from anywhere on
Earth) in January, indicating that January is when Earth is furthest
from the Sun. (You can't see this just by looking, because the Sun is
so blindingly bright and it's a fairly small change, but you can use a
pinhole camera to do it.)


Most people (these kids included) "know" that seasons are caused by
"tilt," but what does that really mean?  It's very useful to take a
globe (on a standard stand tilted by the right amount) and make it
orbit a light source to see how this plays out.  The tilt actually
points to the same place in the sky (judging by the stars) all the
time, but since Earth goes around Sun (or vice versa, it doesn't
matter for this point), for part of the orbit the tilt points the
north pole toward the Sun.  This is northern summer, when there is
midnight Sun near the north pole, and longer daylight hours in
northern latitudes generally.  (You can see this by spinning the globe
in the aforementioned model. Make sure to keep the north pole always
pointing toward the same place in the room, like the clock on the wall,
even as it goes around the "Sun.") Six months later, the Sun is on the
opposite side of Earth (relative to the stars) so it's the south's
turn to have summer and the north pole has constant darkness.  In
between those two extremes, neither hemisphere is favored.

So we are NOT tilted closer to the Sun.  The tilt merely allows the

Sun to shine a greater or lesser fraction of the time on a certain

hemisphere, depending on where the Sun is relative to this constant

tilt.  (This fits the evidence that whatever hemisphere has summer, it

does not see the Sun as closer and bigger.)  Translated into what we

see on the ground, it means that summer is when the Sun rises earlier

and sets later, and goes higher in the sky at noon.  You can see all

these things with the globe and light setup.  I had had the kids keep

a sketch of the position and time of sunset or sunrise each week for

the past six weeks, and these data match the model I just described.

I'll analyze that in a bit more detail, and explore the Moon's orbit

around Earth, in my next visit to the school.