Convection and Weather

This morning I guided the upper-graders at Peregrine School through a
set of weather-related activities.

First, we reviewed what we had learned previously about energy in the
Earth-Sun system.  Briefly, although the Earth's core is very hot and
slowly cooling off due to heat flowing outward through the surface,
the vast majority of heat that we experience comes from the Sun.  How
could we figure that out from everyday observations? Julia nailed it:
the surface temperature varies quite a bit from pole to equator and
from day to night, which is indicative of the Sun rather than of a
constant flow of heat outward in all directions from the Earth's core.
We also reviewed how the Sun heats the ground, not the air (because
air is transparent to visible light); air near the ground is heated by
the ground and that heat then gets mixed throughout the atmosphere.
Whenever something is heated from the bottom, as our atmosphere is,
you get convection (one of the three forms of heat transport we had
discussed earlier).

Convection is the reason we have weather. Hot air rises, cool air
sinks, and so air is always in motion.  To assess the solidity of
their understanding of convection, I immersed a shot-glass full of hot
water (dyed red) into a big container of cool water (dyed ever so
slightly yellow to provide contrast), but first, I asked them to make
predictions about what would happen.  This is a really nice, really
simple experiment or demo.  You can see the hot fluid rising in wisps;
eventually all the red collects on the top half of the large
container.  But the true test of understanding is predicting what
happens when I immerse a shot-glass full of cool water into a big
container of warm water.  The kids showed a good understanding by
predicting that the cool water would not rise at all, and just stay in
the shot-glass (and the bit of cool water which might spill in the
process of setting the shot glass down in the large container would
also settle on the bottom of the large container).  In weather, this
is called an inversion: if cold air gets under a layer of warm air, it
is trapped there, and among other things air pollution can build up in
a city where there's an inversion. (The Wikipedia article on inversion
has some decent pictures, and a Google image search on "weather
inversion" also yields some nice pics.)

Convection transports heat in the oceans as well as in the atmosphere.
There are ocean currents which circulate warm equatorial water toward
northern regions and bring cold water from the north back down toward
the equator to get warmed up again.  The sea off California's coast is
rather cold because the current here comes from Alaska.

But the takeaway message of this part of the day (which took probably
only 20-25 minutes) is that the Sun provides the energy for moving air
around, which makes weather happen.  Because of the way the Sun's
energy hits Earth, hot air must rise from equatorial regions and cold
air must sink near the poles.  But the only way for this to be
sustainable is with a "conveyor belt": hot air which rises from
equatorial regions moves toward the poles, where it cools, sinks, and
moves along the surface back toward the equator.  This creates wind
and weather patterns.  Our next activity was designed to add more
nuance to this general idea.

Before proceeding to the next activity, I presented the class with a
lava lamp for long-term loan.  This will constantly remind them of
convection even when I'm not there!